Global warming is the new religion of First World urban elites

 

Geologist Ian Plimer takes a contrary view, arguing that man-made climate change is a con trick perpetuated by environmentalists

 
 
 
 
The Canadian oilsands industry has been getting a rough ride in recent months in the U.S., where many politicians have lined up to urge restrictions on imports of Canada's 'dirty oil.' California is moving to a low-carbon fuel standard, big-city mayors have targeted oilsands as a driver of global warming, a
 

The Canadian oilsands industry has been getting a rough ride in recent months in the U.S., where many politicians have lined up to urge restrictions on imports of Canada's 'dirty oil.' California is moving to a low-carbon fuel standard, big-city mayors have targeted oilsands as a driver of global warming, a

Photograph by: Tim Fraser/Calgary Herald, Canwest News Service

Ian Plimer has outraged the ayatollahs of purist environmentalism, the Torquemadas of the doctrine of global warming, and he seems to relish the damnation they heap on him.

Plimer is a geologist, professor of mining geology at Adelaide University, and he may well be Australia's best-known and most notorious academic.

Plimer, you see, is an unremitting critic of "anthropogenic global warming" -- man-made climate change to you and me -- and the current environmental orthodoxy that if we change our polluting ways, global warming can be reversed.

It is, of course, not new to have a highly qualified scientist saying that global warming is an entirely natural phenomenon with many precedents in history. Many have made the argument, too, that it is rubbish to contend human behaviour is causing the current climate change. And it has often been well argued that it is totally ridiculous to suppose that changes in human behaviour -- cleaning up our act through expensive slight-of-hand taxation tricks -- can reverse the trend.

But most of these scientific and academic voices have fallen silent in the face of environmental Jacobinism. Purging humankind of its supposed sins of environmental degradation has become a religion with a fanatical and often intolerant priesthood, especially among the First World urban elites.

But Plimer shows no sign of giving way to this orthodoxy and has just published the latest of his six books and 60 academic papers on the subject of global warming. This book, Heaven and Earth -- Global Warming: The Missing Science, draws together much of his previous work. It springs especially from A Short History of Plant Earth, which was based on a decade of radio broadcasts in Australia.

That book, published in 2001, was a best-seller and won several prizes. But Plimer found it hard to find anyone willing to publish this latest book, so intimidating has the environmental lobby become.

But he did eventually find a small publishing house willing to take the gamble and the book has already sold about 30,000 copies in Australia. It seems also to be doing well in Britain and the United States in the first days of publication.

Plimer presents the proposition that anthropogenic global warming is little more than a con trick on the public perpetrated by fundamentalist environmentalists and callously adopted by politicians and government officials who love nothing more than an issue that causes public anxiety.

While environmentalists for the most part draw their conclusions based on climate information gathered in the last few hundred years, geologists, Plimer says, have a time frame stretching back many thousands of millions of years.

The dynamic and changing character of the Earth's climate has always been known by geologists. These changes are cyclical and random, he says. They are not caused or significantly affected by human behaviour.

Polar ice, for example, has been present on the Earth for less than 20 per cent of geological time, Plimer writes. Plus, animal extinctions are an entirely normal part of the Earth's evolution.

(Plimer, by the way, is also a vehement anti-creationist and has been hauled into court for disrupting meetings by religious leaders and evangelists who claim the Bible is literal truth.)

Plimer gets especially upset about carbon dioxide, its role in Earth's daily life and the supposed effects on climate of human manufacture of the gas. He says atmospheric carbon dioxide is now at the lowest levels it has been for 500 million years, and that atmospheric carbon dioxide is only 0.001 per cent of the total amount of the chemical held in the oceans, surface rocks, soils and various life forms. Indeed, Plimer says carbon dioxide is not a pollutant, but a plant food. Plants eat carbon dioxide and excrete oxygen. Human activity, he says, contributes only the tiniest fraction to even the atmospheric presence of carbon dioxide.

There is no problem with global warming, Plimer says repeatedly. He points out that for humans periods of global warming have been times of abundance when civilization made leaps forward. Ice ages, in contrast, have been times when human development slowed or even declined.

So global warming, says Plimer, is something humans should welcome and embrace as a harbinger of good times to come.

jmanthorpe@vancouversun.com

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
The Canadian oilsands industry has been getting a rough ride in recent months in the U.S., where many politicians have lined up to urge restrictions on imports of Canada's 'dirty oil.' California is moving to a low-carbon fuel standard, big-city mayors have targeted oilsands as a driver of global warming, a
 

The Canadian oilsands industry has been getting a rough ride in recent months in the U.S., where many politicians have lined up to urge restrictions on imports of Canada's 'dirty oil.' California is moving to a low-carbon fuel standard, big-city mayors have targeted oilsands as a driver of global warming, a

Photograph by: Tim Fraser/Calgary Herald, Canwest News Service

 
 
 
 
 
 
 

More Photo Galleries

Fashion Today

Today in Fashion, July 29

Highlights from fashion shows in Colombia and the ...

 
Phoenix Suns' Steve Nash, Victoria's own NBA star

Gallery: Steve Nash, Victoria'...

Steve Nash and the Phoenix Suns are returning to Vancouver...

 
Celebrity Today

Gallery: Today in Celebrity, July...

Katy Perry, Rihanna, Mickey Rourke, celeb animals ...

 
 
 
 
Herb Fowler
 
July 29, 2009 - 10:41 AM
 
 Watch The Great Global Warming Scandal on u tube. It's very good and supports what is being said here. Global Warming precedes elevated co2 in our atmosphere by hundreds of years. This is done by warming the ocean temperatures, which releases co2 in our atmosphere. Carbon taxes help fund global Eugenics programs.
   
 
Herb Fowler
 
July 29, 2009 - 10:41 AM
 
 Watch The Great Global Warming Scandal on u tube. It's very good and supports what is being said here. Global Warming precedes elevated co2 in our atmosphere by hundreds of years. This is done by warming the ocean temperatures, which releases co2 in our atmosphere. Carbon taxes help fund global Eugenics programs.
   
 
chip
 
July 29, 2009 - 10:41 AM
 
 

I too embraced AGW until I looked into it further. There are some 'inconvenient truths' if yo will. Much of the theory is based on computer modeling that uses mathematical assumptions in the place of gaping holes in the data, and these models have not been very accurate. The didn't predict for example that the earth would cool over the last decade. The models also predict that most warming should occur in the troposphere, something that has not been borne out.

Equally troubling is the veracity of the data we do have. The world's most complete temperature network - in the US - has been shown to be compromised, with over 80% of the stations not conforming to their standards in terms of isolation fro local heat sources such as roads and airport runways.

Finally, there never really was a consensus for AGW: the media was just loathe to report contrary views. But this non-consensus is fragmenting further as more evidence mounts about the role of the sun on temperature. Last week, the Americal Physical Society -- the world's second-biggest organization of physicists -- announced it was reconsidering its support for AGW.

For further reading on the subject of AGW, these sites are good:

www.wattsupwiththat.com

www.climateaudit.com

   
 
chip
 
July 29, 2009 - 10:38 AM
 
 I too embraced AGW until I looked into it further. There are some 'inconvenient truths' if yo will. Much of the theory is based on computer modeling that uses mathematical assumptions in the place of gaping holes in the data, and these models have not been very accurate. The didn't predict for example that the earth would cool over the last decade. The models also predict that most warming should occur in the troposphere, something that has not been borne out. Equally troubling is the veracity of the data we do have. The world's most complete temperature network - in the US - has been shown to be compromised, with over 80% of the stations not conforming to their standards in terms of isolation fro local heat sources such as roads and airport runways. Finally, there never really was a consensus for AGW: the media was just loathe to report contrary views. But this non-consensus is fragmenting further as more evidence mounts about the role of the sun on temperature. Last week, the Americal Physical Society -- the world's second-biggest organization of physicists -- announced it was reconsidering its support for AGW. For further reading on the subject of AGW, these sites are good: www.wattsupwiththat.com www.climateaudit.com
   
 
Herb Fowler
 
July 29, 2009 - 10:36 AM
 
 Watch The Great Global Warming Scandal on u tube. It's very good and supports what is being said here. Global Warming precedes elevated co2 in our atmosphere by hundreds of years. This is done by warming the ocean temperatures, which releases co2 in our atmosphere. Carbon taxes help fund global Eugenics programs.
   
 
UyeahU
 
July 29, 2009 - 10:36 AM
 
 Likely caused by the sun, if at all, global warming is nothing more than a new way to gouge the citizens of America (and the world) with more taxes. No doubt a hidden tax, so the overtaxed sheeple won't bleat too much.
   
 
UyeahU
 
July 29, 2009 - 10:36 AM
 
 Likely caused by the sun, if at all, global warming is nothing more than a new way to gouge the citizens of America (and the world) with more taxes. No doubt a hidden tax, so the overtaxed sheeple won't bleat too much.
   
 
Herb Fowler
 
July 29, 2009 - 10:35 AM
 
 Watch The Great Global Warming Scandal on u tube. It's very good and supports what is being said here. Global Warming precedes elevated co2 in our atmosphere by hundreds of years. This is done by warming the ocean temperatures, which releases co2 in our atmosphere. Carbon taxes help fund global Eugenics programs.
   
 
UyeahU
 
July 29, 2009 - 10:33 AM
 
 Likely caused by the sun, if at all, global warming is nothing more than a new way to gouge the citizens of America (and the world) with more taxes. No doubt a hidden tax, so the overtaxed sheeple won't bleat too much.
   
 
Edward
 
July 29, 2009 - 10:28 AM
 
 In the simplest terms possible, the main reason man made global warming is a scam, one need only look at the composition of the earths atmosphere which is made up of 0.038% CO2 which you can literally call zero point zero. A good analogy of mans contribution to this, is putting a drop of ink into the Pacific ocean and then claiming the ocean is polluted because of that drop. Also the main villian of global warming is not CO2 but water vapor. Shall we start banning water as well?
   
 
Kathleen
 
July 29, 2009 - 10:27 AM
 
 AMEN and AMEN! At last - a voice of reason! The US and Europe are the biggest perpetrators of this global warming myth. Millions of dollars are being spent on this hoax. I am still baffled that Al Gore got the Nobel Peace Prize instead of Irena Sendler, who smuggled Jews out of Poland. What a bunch of idiots! Global warming is nothing more than Chicken Little running around screaming "the sky is falling"! It's amazing how gullible people are regarding this hoax, and have followed blindly without researching the facts. Thank you, Ian Plimer, for using wisdom and common sense instead of political correctness.
   
 
Shamslam
 
July 29, 2009 - 10:27 AM
 
 Huzzah!! Finally some reason in all this madness! Keep it up, prof.
   
 
jim
 
July 29, 2009 - 9:58 AM
 
 mmm
   
 
Doc
 
July 29, 2009 - 9:58 AM
 
 Heretic! Call the hate speech police. We western sinners must pay our indulgances to high priest Gore by buying his carbon credits for our evil carbon producing lifestles. We even breath out carbon, proving our original sin. Father David Suzuki has publically called for people that ignore the "science" of climate change to be thrown in jail. There is no time for discussion or rational debate we must act now or in 100 years time it may be 2 degrees colder!
   
 
Ellen
 
July 29, 2009 - 9:58 AM
 
 So glad to see there are still scientists who are willing to stand behind the science even when it is not popular.
   
 
all»
 
 
Keep it clean, and stay on the subject or we might delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. You must have a javascript enabled browser to submit a comment.
 
Your Name
 
Your Comment
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Breaking News Alerts

 
Sign up to receive e-mail alerts on breaking news from The Vancouver Sun.
 
 
 

Latest updates

http://a123.g.akamai.net/f/123/12465/1d/www.vancouversun.com/news/difficult+control+fire+advancing+toward+small+communities/1841347/pregnant.jpg

Pregnant women top list for swine flu vaccine in U.S.

Pregnant women are first on a list of target groups to be given a swine flu vaccine in the United States, according to the recommendations presented Wednesday...

3 hours ago
 
 
 
 
 
What Is Global Warming?
 
Is It All A Hoax?
 
Find Out At National Geographic
 
NationalGeographic.com
global warming
 
Simple Tips to Cool The Planet
 
The Difference Starts in California
 
www.fypower.org
Climate Watch
 
Cutting water usage by 20% without
 
requiring three-minute showers.
 
www.kqed.org/climatewatch